Bookbyte Blog

Posted by Reddit user snerro

Posted by Reddit user snerro

A thread on Reddit with the above image kicked off an interesting discussion by teachers and students on the value of memorization in education. As often happens with stuff we find on Reddit, we carried the discussion back into the office, and not all of us were on the same page. Here’s what we thought:

Gavin

I’m a big promoter of practical testing. I don’t think ‘multiple guess’ tests really show anyone what you know or how well you can apply that knowledge, but mostly if you are a good test taker or not. Out in the real world you are rewarded for your ability to problem solve and find the answers, rather than knowing an answer from memory. Furthermore I am also a fan of portfolios vs. test scores to showcase one’s knowledge and achievements. I would say I strongly agree with the puffin.

Jesse

While having an open book test could encourage resourcefulness, you still have to know, roughly, where in your notes or text the answer can be found.  To me, it sounds like you’re taking the risk of spending more time on the back end, during the physical test, than on the front end by actually knowing and understanding the material. If I’m having open heart surgery do I want my surgeon to have an anatomy chart open on the table while he’s cutting me open? Or how much time does it waste when your cashier has to look up each and every code of every item you purchase? I’ll take my chances on a med student that’s been forced to memorize everything or general edu student that’s taken the time and effort to memorize their class materials over someone who hasn’t.

Justin

I’m not a fan of standardized testing as I don’t believe it accurately reflects one’s intelligence. People in the real world are allowed to use their resources, pool their knowledge with others, collaborate and problem solve to come to a conclusion. I think the meme is accurate in that memorization is not education; memorization is just one of many tools that you have. One’s score or overall intelligence shouldn’t be solely tied to that.

Holly

Textbooks can be a convoluted mess. I always thought that I would do a better job on a test if it was open book, but I spent so much time searching for answers that I would skirt the line of completing a test on time. Cramming for a test only helped me to take tests faster. Memorizing enough information to answer correctly or with an educated guess always proved successful for me, so I didn’t have a problem with it. I disagree with the advice puffin. Yes, it’s true that in real life you have an opportunity to ask someone for help. But it’s also important to have a base knowledge in place.

Chris

I don’t think this issue is as much about the merits of memorization as it is about whether or not a test is well-designed. The point of a test is to apply knowledge, sure, but writing a persuasive essay, making an educated guess, and solving for X are all different valid ways to apply knowledge. That variety is important, since each type of test exercises a different skill set. I wouldn’t ever argue that all tests should be open book, but I think they get too needlessly stressful when they’re designed in a way that tries both your ability to recall and your ability to apply, like an art history final where you need to remember exact spelling for Islamic art and artists. (This one happened to me, extra ridiculousness points because those names and terms were transliterated from Arabic anyway.)

What do you think?

About these ads

Comments on: "Should All Tests Be Open Book?" (4)

  1. I like Jesse’s response. “Hey, does anyone remember what body part this is? I can’t remember. Where does this blood vessel lead to? Should I cut here? What do you think? We should have a library in here… Wait, someone go get a laptop. Maybe someone has a YouTube video of someone performing heart surgery.”

    This is a good essay topic. Education should not be about the “treasure hunt” for the answer to a question. Education should be about discerning valid rhetoric, separating facts from fiction, contemplating downstream effects, and holistically evaluating systems, not simply regurgitating details about circumstances or events.

    On the other hand, we often do seek out advice and guidance. But we hopefully direct our queries towards people whose knowledge and experience outweighs our own. We don’t want to surround ourselves by those whose answer to all things is to “Google that stuff.”

  2. BTW, your “Comment” area is broken. Clicking Twitter leads to WordPress, and the fields are not populated with the correct details. For instance, the Twitter login fields yields “twitter_username@twitter.domain.com.” The field should submit, “twitter_username@twitter.com” for the form to work. Someone needs to look into this so people can actually post feedback without having to tweak their details. Just a thought :)

  3. I think tests should be open book. As you search for the answers you are reaffirming your knowledge of the subject. I think your problem-solving skills are more valuable than memorization. How do you handle stress is more valuable. You may have a person who is very good at memorization, but can they apply the information into real-life applications. Now that is the true test of what you have learned.

  4. Sean Gayle said:

    I am reading a lot of responses that to me differentiate between mastery learning and rote learning. How many of you would like to be operated on by a surgeon without proven mastery learning? On the other hand, rote learning is good because a lot “sticks” and can be referred to later. I learned more in College from how to use reference materials and how to correlate the information into life studies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 65 other followers

%d bloggers like this: